It’s weird to think that its been 10 years since the last Hobbit film came out and apart from the Amazon TV series, there hasnt been much in the way of stuff from Middle Earth but despite us getting a Gollum movie (at some point) we now get an animated film which is set 183 years before the Lord of the Rings trilogy and sees a war between Wulf and Helm Hammerhead and Helm killed Wulf’s dad and that is the simple enough plot. It’s nice that there isnt world ending implications in the plot and that its a self contained story.
GOOD POINTS
Nice to be back in Middle Earth
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is one of the greatest trilogies in movie history and whilst the Hobbit trilogy had issues (it shouldn't have been a trilogy), it was nice to be back in middle earth and after a decade away, its good to be back in familiar places. Even though it's 183 years before we would be back here in The Two Towers, the animation manages to take us back there and despite it not being live action, I still felt like I was there.
Brian Cox is a good Helm Hammerhead
It’s nice to see Brian Cox do something where he is playing a nice guy. Having watched and enjoyed him in Succession and his instantly recognisable voice is great to hear and it fits the character perfectly. It's so easy to get casting wrong in animated films but they struck gold when they cast Cox. The character is a likeable person and Cox’s voice makes you like him and want him to be victorious.
Animation is beautiful
The animation does have a feel of a Studio Ghibli and it's stunning from start to finish. The only thing I wasn't keen on was the fire which looked like live action instead of animated. This felt like a weird choice because it didn't need to look real and looked really out of place. That’s the only real criticism with the animation because as I said it looks beautiful and the colours are nice and the grading all add to give us what we have in the film.
Wulf is a good villain
A film can be successful or not depending on how effective the antagonist is and in the case of this film, Wulf is an effective villain. He is focused on his goal to the point where he forgo logic just to win his personal battle. It might come across as a bit weak to other but sometimes personal motives work just as well as wanting something for power and if its done well then I dont mind personal motives for moving a story along.
BAD POINTS
Bit too long
At 2 hours and 15 minutes it is about 40 minutes to long. It didn't need to be any longer than 90 minutes. Animated films work better when they have a shorter running time. Toy Story is only 81 minutes long so why this film is over two hours is a mystery to me. A shorter run time can lead to a pacier film and that is something that could work in a film's favour.
Slightly pointless
As much as I loved being back in Middle Earth, the film did feel like it was slightly pointless. It doesnt lead into anything that is coming out soon, it doesnt connect to anything beyond the Lord of the Rings films and so it doesnt feel like its a must see thing which is a shame and it is worth seeing but I dont think many people beyond Lord of the Rings fans will bother even tracking it down.
OVERALL
I enjoyed this animated film. It had a good story which would have benefited from a shorter running time. We are suppose to be getting a Gollum movie at somepoint which will get a lot more attention than this film has received which is a shame because it is worth your time but it might be quite low in your rankings of best Middle Earth stories.
No comments:
Post a Comment