There are two ways of doing a cash grab movie. One is subtle, which is to take something that people like and give us a new instalment in that series (TRON Ares) and then there are the more blatant ones like 2026’s Moana which continues Disney's ongoing mission to turn their animated back catalogue into live action. What is strange about this movie is that the original animated version is only 10 years old. It hasn’t had time to develop a cult like following to get people excited by it.
The plot of this follows the original so there is no point going into that but there are subtle differences which were most likely done more for budgetary reasons than anything else. The performances were all really good. I thought that Catherine Laga’aia played Moana as someone who wants to help her people and yet be an adventuress even though her father doesn't want her going beyond a certain point. Laga’aia and Dwayne Johnson’s dynamic works very well and like in the 2016 version, its the main thing to like in this. Dwayne Johnson brings his usual charm and charisma to the role of Maui but I am sorry its the hair that I found distracting. When I saw the trailer I could have been convinced it was an SNL sketch because the wig looks cheap. It looks like he is wearing a wig which isn't the point of a wig unless you plan to make it part of the story. I thought that rest of the performances were really good as well with John Tui as Moana’s father Chief Tui, Frankie Adams as Moana’s mother Sina delivery lovely performances but I thought that Rena Owen stood out as Gramma Tala. Her performance might come across as cliched by Disney standards but it was lovely and the scene where Moana leaves just as Gramma is dying is beautifully done by both Laga’aia and Owen.
The songs are all really good although I think that Laga’aia struggles with the ‘How Far I’ll Go’ song but the advantage of having Johnson star in both versions is this version of ‘Your Welcome’ is as good here as it was in 2016. Mark Mancina is another constant from 2016 and I think does a great job here.
Moana isn't bad by any means but it does feel largely pointless. The story is basically the 2016 version with some subtle differences and it directed competently by Thomas Kail. As I said earlier, not enough time has passed for people to get nostalgic about it. On a side note, I saw this in IMAX which is the first time I have seen a film in this format and to be honest I thought it was quite good. The size of the screen was massive and sitting in my usual spot in a screening (front row, furthest seat away from the entrance) meant I got a great experience. Moana should be a cautionary tale of how not to do a cash grab movie. You need to leave films at least a generation before remaking them.